Main Office
9323 Union Cemetery Road
Loveland, OH 45140
Tel.: (513) 683-6644
Fax: (513) 683-6626
 
Back to SymmsTownship.com
News and Updates
Agenda & Minutes
Township Events
Township Officials
Tourism Information
Municipal Facilities
Construction Information and Updates
Master Plan
Contact Us

MINUTES OF
SYMMES TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES
REGULAR MEETING
JANUARY 5, 2010

This meeting can be viewed on demand through an interactive agenda by clicking: HERE

Opening | Receipts | Warrants | Reports | Correspondence | Zoning and Planning Issues | New Business | Executive Session

Opening

The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m.  Members of the Board present were: Mr. Philip Beck, Mr. Kenneth Bryant, Mrs. Jodie Leis, and Mr. John Borchers.

Also present:  Gerald Beckman - Township Administrator; Robert Malloy - Township Law Director; Carol Sims - Township Assistant Fiscal Officer; Lt. Thomas Butler - Hamilton County Sheriff's Department; Otto Huber - Chief, Loveland Symmes Fire Department.

KENNETH BRYANT presented his bond to the Board of Trustees.  John Borchers administered the oath of office to Trustee Bryant who was elected in November to a four-year term.

JODIE LEIS presented her bond to the Board of Trustees.  Sheriff Simon Leis administered the oath of office to Trustee Leis who was elected in November to a four-year term.

Mr. Borchers announced a brief reception would be held.

The meeting re-convened at 7:25 p.m.

ORGANIZATION OF THE BOARD

MR. BORCHERS asked for nominations for President of the Board and noted that a second would not be required.

MR. BRYANT moved to appoint Phil Beck as President of the Board.  The motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mrs. Leis - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mr. Beck - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to appoint Ken Bryant as Vice President.  Mrs. Leis seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mrs. Leis - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mr. Beck - 'aye'.

MR. BECK announced that Trustee meetings for 2010 will continue to be held on the first Tuesday each month at 7:00 p.m., with Special meetings scheduled as needed.

Mr. Beck announced that the salary for the Township Trustees will be $20,568.00 and will be paid in monthly installments.  The salary for the Township Fiscal Officer will be $28,176.00 per year, paid in monthly installments.

Mr. Beck announced that members of the Township Zoning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals will receive $50.00 per meeting.

Mr. Beck announced that the Employee Personnel Policy will remain the same and that the Holiday schedule will remain as outlined in said policy manual.

Mr. Beck announced that the Township will continue its contract with the Loveland Symmes Fire Department at an annual fee of $1,873,069.10 and that the Township will continue its contract with the Hamilton County Sheriff's Patrol.

Mr. Beck announced that the Trustees will continue the employee reimbursement for cell phones in the amount of $700.00 to employees who use their own phone/service and in the amount of $550.00 to employees who use a Township phone.

The following appointments were made by the Board:

       John Borchers as the Board Representative to Finance & Audit Committee;
       Jodie Leis as the Board Representative to the Ad Hoc Park Expansion Committee; 
       Ken Bryant as the Board Representative to the Ad Hoc Community Reinvestment Area Committee;
       Phil Beck as the Board Representative and Jodie Leis as the Alternate to C.L.O.U.T.;
       Jodie Leis as the Board Representative to Hamilton County Planning Partnership;
       Jodie Leis as the Board Representative to Hamilton County General Health District Advisory Council;
       Ken Bryant as the Township Representative to ICRC;
       Phil Beck as the Township Representative to the Hamilton County Township Association;
       Jerry Beckman as the Township Representative to the Hamilton County Tax Incentive Review Council;
        Bill Pitman as the Township Representative to Hamilton County Township Road Superintendents Association.

Back to Top

Receipts

Receipts totaling $51,471.40 were read and accepted.

Back to Top

Warrants

MR. BECK moved that the Township pay its bills.  Mr. Bryant seconded the motion and all voted 'aye'. Proper certification having been made, warrants totaling $9,783,037.19 were issued.

Back to Top

Reports

GERALD BECKMAN -  Reported on activities in the township since the last meeting:

1.  PATRILLA NUISANCE - Presented pictures to the Board and advised this nuisance has been abated.  Mr. Beckman stated he will review this property throughout the year to make sure that the owner remains in compliance.

2.  COUNTY ENERGY RESOLUTION - Advised a revised resolution has been received.  Mr. Beckman recommended that the Board take no action until the next meeting to allow for review by the Township Law Director.

MR. BRYANT questioned the timing on this issue.

MR. BECKMAN advise that the Board has at least six weeks.

MR. MALLOY stated he would be able to review this resolution and report to the Board at the next meeting.

3.  ADMINISTRATOR LOG - Noted that a "draft" log and numbering system was attached to the recent Administrator's Report and questioned if the Board had any suggestions before finalizing the format.

MR. BRYANT stated he felt this log will help in creating a history on Township items.

The Board had no suggestions for Mr. Beckman.

CHIEF HUBER -  Presented the Board with the Camp Dennison water flow report for further discussion at the next meeting.

MR. BRYANT questioned how this timing works based on the contract negotiations between Indian Hill and Hamilton County Public Works.

MR. BECKMAN advised copies of information has been sent to the various parties and was not aware of a need for immediate action by the Board.  Mr. Beckman further advised that he will make inquiries and keep the Board apprised.

OTHER -  MR. BECKMAN questioned when the Board wished to review the proposed design for the development of the Rozzi park property.  Mr. Beckman suggested the Board hold a Special Meeting and invite the Ad Hoc Park Committee to attend.  The design development drawings can be started when the Board finalizes the design.

MR. BORCHERS advised he has met with Turner Construction on the construction manager contract.  Mr. Borchers noted that Turner Construction is already working with McGill Smith Punshon to develop timeframe, etc.  Mr. Borchers stated he would have a recommendation at the February meeting.

MR. BECK moved to hold a Special Meeting on January 19, 2010 at 7:00 p.m for the purpose of reviewing and discussing the proposed design concept for development of the Rozzi park property.  Mrs. Leis seconded the motion.

MR. BRYANT stated the Ad Hoc Park Expansion Committee met some time ago to review proposed concepts.  The Committee made a recommendation; however, they have not seen this hybrid design.

The roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECKMAN stated he would invite the Ad Hoc Park Expansion Committee to this special meeting.

 

Back to Top

Executive Session

MR. BECK moved that the Board enter Executive Session for the purpose of discussing the appointment of a public employee and the purchase of real property.  Mr. Bryant seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows:  Mrs. Leis - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mr. Beck - 'aye'.  The meeting adjourned for Executive Session at 8:02 p.m.

The meeting reconvened from Executive Session at 8:30 p.m.

Back to Top

Correspondence

cc:COUNTY DEV CO to SYCAMORE TWP - Notice of CRA request from Kenda LLC for 10670 Loveland Madeira Road.

BUREAU OF MOTOR VEHICLE - Letter regarding recent Loveland audit.

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS - Letter regarding Energy Efficiency Community Block Grants.

SEALED BIDS FOR ROZZI DEMOLITION PROJECT received from:
a.  Jergens Construction
b.  Evans Landscaping
c.  A. Bonamase Contractors
d.  Rauch Inc.
e.  Facility Management
f.  Baumann Enterprise
g.  Empire Corp.
h.  C&M Woodcrafters
i.  O'Rourke
j.  Fiscus Trucking
k.  Kellerman Co.
l.  Logan Creek LLC
m.  Cox Paving
n.  Allgeier & Con
o.  So. Ohio Sealcoating
p.  Demolition Inc.
q.  Plainville Equipment       

HARLAN TWP - Letter of appreciation for donation of recording equipment.

COUNTY DEV CO - Letter regarding ULAP 2010 Funding Round.

LOGAN CREEK LLC - e-mail with references for Rozzi Demolition Project.

USI INS - e-mail regarding approval for insurance participation.

NICK KURZYNSKI - e-mail regarding proposed wording for historic marker for Meade House.

KEVIN McMURRAY - e-mail response to question regarding clean-up of area on Rozzi property.
MOODY'S INVESTORS SERVICE - e-mail regarding MIG 1 rating for Township.

cc:PAYNE FIRM to KEVIN McMURRAY - e-mail regarding soil samples from Rozzi property.

JMA - e-mail regarding status of easement play for Bainwoods storm sewer.

SHERIFF'S DEPT - October and November activity reports and letter regarding patrol car bid for 2010.

McGILL SMITH - e-mail regarding possible grant money available for new park.

ROBERT GOERING, HAMILTON COUNTY TREASURER - Notice of Collection of Inheritance Taxes ($7,224.35).   

RITTGERS & RITTGERS - Public Records Request.

BOARD OF ELECTIONS - Certificate of election results for ballot issues.

COUNTY DEV CO - e-mail regarding proposed CRA on Loveland Madeira.

PERSO - Notice that claim for 2009 GMC has been closed.

JULIE BYRNE, 9178 PINEWOOD (45140) - Application for BZA.

RBC - Letter regarding Park Land Acquisition Bond Anticipation Notes.

RUSS SPARKS - e-mail regarding letter from County Engineer regarding landscaping at Kroger development.

cc:COUNTY AUDITOR to CONTADINO PROPERTIES - Letter regarding tax abatement for property at 11210 Montgomery Road.

COUNTY ENGINEER - 2009 Bridge Report.

COUNTY AUDITOR - Ten Mill Tax Certificate.

PRESS COMMUNITY - e-mail to Kathy Wagner regarding term as Trustee.

SYMMES FIRE DEPT BOARD OF DIRECTORS - Annual report.

OHIO PUBLIC WORKS - Notice of payment to Freeze Underground for Kempergrove Headwall Project.

LT. BUTLER - e-mail regarding recent sale of property near Safety Center.

cc:WOOD & LAMPING to CAR WASH PLUS - Letter regarding outstanding balance due for Chapelsquare rent payments.

COUNTY ENGINEER - Notice Township has been awarded SCIP funds for Bainwoods Headwall project.

COUNTY PROSECUTOR - Notice of property offered for sale to Township (Parcel 62000610037).

HC NUTTING - Field report for Kempergrove project.

COUNTY PROSECUTOR - Notice of property offered for sale to Township (Parcel 6201220054).

COUNTY AUDITOR -
a.  Amended Certificate of Estimated Resources
b.  Amended Certificate of Appropriations        

SYMMES FIRE DEPT - e-mail regarding personnel.

COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS - e-mail regarding water contract with Indian Hill.

cc:HCDC to SYCAMORE SCHOOLS - Letter regarding proposed CRA for 10670 Loveland Madeira Road.

ADVANCED CONTRACTORS - Request for review Construction Manager proposals.

RBC - Letter regarding the Township's investment policy statement.

KLH ENGINEERS - Report on HVAC inspection at Safety Center.

WOOD & LAMPING - e-mail regarding COBRA.

DUKE ENERGY - Letter regarding application of Duke Energy Ohio for Adjustment to Rider AMRP rates.

WOOD & LAMPING - Legal opinion regarding Kathy Wagner's COBRA benefits.

USI INSURANCE - e-mail confirmation that Symmes Township has been accepted into insurance plan.

LELAND COLE - Note of appreciation for Ms. Sims.

USI INSURANCE - e-mail listing of employees going to high deductible plan.

JMA - Letter regarding Kempergrove project request for payment.

WOOD & LAMPING to ROZZI - Letter regarding payment of expenses for recent explosion on property.

US CENSUS - Letter regarding upcoming census.

PERSO - Notice claim closed on salt dome roof.

cc:BUREAU MOTOR VEHICLES to LOVELAND - Letter regarding 2009 audit findings.

US COURT - Note regarding class action settlement against Sprint.

McGILL SMITH - e-mail regarding Rozzi property.

SHERIFF DEPT - Notice of snow emergency information.

WOOD & LAMPING - e-mail regarding claim filed by Erwin Walker.

MERCY FRANCISCAN ST JOHN - Letter of appreciation for participation in Adopt-A-Family by Township employees.

RELIANCE LIFE - e-mail regarding employee changes.

COMMUNITY PRESS - e-mail requesting for updated photos and contact information.

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS - Letter regarding increase in dispatch fees for 2010 to $1438.00 per month.

REGIONAL PLANNING - Memo regarding annual membership renewal.

FRANK GATES - Letter regarding Worker Comp. reports.

SHERIFF DEPT - e-mail regarding recent break-ins.

SYMMES FIRE - Camp Dennison Fire Flow Report.

HAROLD SUDDARTH - Notice of retirement effective March 1, 2010.

 

Back to Top

Zoning and Planning Issues

MR. BECK moved to re-appoint Ralph Wolfe, 8311 Hambletonian (45249) to the Board of Zoning Appeals for the term ending December 31, 2014.  Mrs. Leis seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

Back to Top

New Business

 MR. BECK moved to adopt the following resolution and to dispense with the second reading:


RESOLUTION G-2010-01
               Resolution Appointing Robert P. Malloy
           Law Director Pursuant to R.C. 504.15 and
  Dispensing with the Second Reading

               WHEREAS, pursuant to R.C. 504.15, the Board of Trustees is required to appoint a full-time or part-time Law Director; and

               WHEREAS, Robert P. Malloy is by reason of his training and experience competent to act as legal advisor to the Board, the Township Administrator and other Township officers; and

               WHEREAS, R.C. 504.151 provides that the Township Law Director may appoint as Assistant Law Director a person who is an associate or partner of or who is employed by the Township Law Director in the private practice of law; and

               WHEREAS, certain associates, partners and employees of Robert P. Malloy are qualified and capable of assisting and supporting the legal services.

               NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Trustees of Symmes Township, Hamilton County, Ohio pursuant to Chapter 504 of the Revised Code, as follows:

               Section 1.     Robert P. Malloy is hereby appointed and retained pursuant to R.C. 504.15 as the Township Law Director who shall serve in such capacity on a part-time basis as an independent contractor unless terminated by the Board or Robert P. Malloy upon thirty (30) days notice. Robert P. Malloy shall be compensated for such services at the rate of One Thousand Five Hundred and Eighty Dollars ($1,580.00) per month. Services in excess of twelve (12) hours per month shall be paid monthly at the rate of One Hundred Fifty-Eight Dollars ($158.00) per hour, plus authorized expenses, except that legal services rendered for matters involving litigation or administrative appeals shall be compensated at the rate of One Hundred Eighty-Four Dollars ($184.00) per hour. Such a rate of compensation shall also be applicable for legal services performed by other persons in the law firm of Wood & Lamping who are so designated as Assistant Law Directors by Robert P. Malloy.

                Section 2.     The Board hereby authorized and directs that the Township enter into a Law Director Employment Agreement with Robert P. Malloy, which Agreement fully defines the terms and conditions upon which Robert P. Malloy shall serve as Law Director, a copy of which is incorporated herein by reference as Exhibit “A.”

                 Section 3.     The Trustees of Symmes Township upon majority vote do hereby dispense with the requirement that this Resolution be read on two separate days, and hereby authorize the adoption of this Resolution upon its first reading.

                 Section 4.     This Resolution shall be adopted as an emergency necessary for the immediate preservation of the public, peace, health, safety or welfare of the community for the reason that it is necessary to maintain the continuity of legal services for this Township.

                  Section 5.     It is hereby determined that all formal actions of the Board of Trustees relating to the adoption of this Resolution were taken in an open meeting of the Board of Township Trustees and that all deliberations of such Board of Trustees were in meeting open to the public, in compliance with all legal requirements, including Section 121.22 of the Ohio Revised Code.

MR. BRYANT seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to adopt the following resolution and to dispense with the second reading:

RESOLUTION G-2010-02
       Resolution Retaining Chester Willcox & Saxbe
           as Legal Counsel to Advise and Represent
the Township in Annexation Matters

                   WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees of Symmes Township, Hamilton County, Ohio, deems it necessary and advisable to employ legal counsel to advise and represent the Township on legal matters relating to annexation;

                   NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Trustees of Symmes Township that:

                   Section 1.     Elizabeth M. Stanton and the firm of Chester Willcox & Saxbe, A Legal Professional Association, be retained as Legal Counsel to advise and represent Symmes Township on legal matters relating to annexation.

                   Section 2.     Representation will be paid for as follows: $225.00 per hour senior attorney time; $180.00 per hour associate attorney time; and $85.00 per hour law clerk or legal assistant time.  Rate is fixed for six months but subject to increase thereafter, with a maximum increase of six (6%) percent every six (6) months.  Time spent on travel and telephone calls is considered billable time.  Court costs and expenses will be paid by the Township.  Fees will be paid monthly upon receipt of the bill.

               Section 3.     Board will execute a Retainer Agreement reciting these terms.

               Section 4.     The Fiscal Officer is hereby authorized and directed to pay for the above services from the Township fund from and after January 1, 2010.

               Section 5.     That this action by order of the Board of Trustees of Symmes Township be duly entered upon its journal.

               Section 6.     This Resolution shall be adopted as an emergency necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or welfare of the community for the reason that it is necessary to maintain the continuity of legal services for this Township.

MRS. LEIS seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to adopt the following resolution:



RESOLUTION G-2010-03
               Resolution Requesting the County
      Auditor to Make Advance Payments of Taxes

               WHEREAS, the Ohio revised Code allows a taxing authority to request payment from the County Auditor funds derived from taxes or other sources to the County Treasurer, which is held on account of a local subdivision; and

               WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees of Symmes Township, Hamilton County, Ohio, wishes the Township Fiscal Officer to make requests for advance payments of property taxes prior to the completion of a tax settlement.

               NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Trustees of Symmes Township, Hamilton County, Ohio:

               Section 1.     That the Auditor and Treasurer of Hamilton County, Ohio, in accordance with Ohio Revised Code Section 321.34, be requested to draw and pay to Symmes Township upon written request of John C. Borchers, Fiscal Officer to the County Auditor, funds due in any settlement of 2010 derived from taxes or other sources, payment to the County Treasurer to the account of Symmes Township, and lawfully applicable for purposes of the current fiscal year.

               Section 2.     That the Fiscal Officer is hereby directed to forward a certified copy of this Resolution to the County Auditor.

MR. BRYANT seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECKMAN reviewed the list of streets recommended by the Director of Public Works for resurfacing this year.  The estimated cost has been compared against the available appropriation.  The Board had no objection to the proposed streets. 

Mr. Beckman advised he will be asking the Board in February to establish a bid opening date for this project.

MR. BECKMAN advised that Staff is looking for direction from the Board regarding special events for 2010.

MRS. LEIS stated she would like to have an Easter Egg Hunt as this is a way for residents to meet during a community event. 

MR. BRYANT noted the Township has not held an Easter Egg Hunt for the last two years.  The first year because Easter came so early and last year because of the preparation for the Flower Show.

MR. BECK stated the Flower this year will be April 17 - 25.  It appears that the date for an Easter Egg Hunt would be Saturday, March 27 at Symmes Elementary.

MR. BRYANT questioned if the Township would attempt to get volunteers again.

MR. BECKMAN advised the Township has not been successful in having residents volunteer for the various events.

MRS. LEIS stated she would be able to get as many volunteers as needed.

MR. BECKMAN advised the other events would be Symmesfest in June, Fallfest in October and Operation Santa in December.

Mr. Beckman noted that the Township last year assisted the Cincinnati Horticultural Society with Farmfest since they did not have a sponsor.

MR. BRYANT stated that the Township originally held Fallfest on a Sunday and funded this event.  The Township, due to its association with the Horticultural Society, allowed the Society to use Symmes Park for its annual Farmfest.  The Board combined these two events last year to increase participation on Friday and Saturday. 

MR. BECK noted that Operation Santa is held on December 5 which will be Sunday this year. 

MR. BRYANT moved that Symmes Township hold four special events (Easter Egg Hunt, Symmesfest, Farmfest and Operation Santa) during 2010 and to approve an expenditure in an amount not to exceed $20,000.00 for expenses for said events.  Mr. Beck seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to accept the notice of retirement received from Harold Suddarth effective March 1, 2010.  Mrs. Leis seconded the motion.

MR. BECKMAN advised that Mr. Suddarth has been with the Township for seventeen years and has decided to retire.

The roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to approve a one year supplemental contract by the Loveland Symmes Fire Department with Milford Fire Department for the Camp Dennison area at $500.00 per month effective January 1, 2010.  Mr. Bryant seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to approve:
               a.      Additional expenditure in the amount of $2,500.00 for asbestos removal from structures located on Rozzi Park property Center
               b.      Expenditure in an amount not to exceed $26,028.00 for the purchase of a police cruiser
               c.      Expenditure in the amount of $1,873.00 for 2010 membership fee (1/2 participation) in the Hamilton County Regional Planning Commission and the Planning Partnership
               d.      Expenditure (Then & Now) in the amount of $2,182.86 for repairs to recording system
               e.      Additional expenditure in the amount of $9,282.00 for purchase of salt
Mr. Bryant seconded the motion.

MR. BECKMAN stated there is a need for the replacement of two cruisers due to high mileage.

MR. BORCHERS noted that only one police cruiser was budgeted.  Mr. Borchers stated that this second cruiser would need to be purchased from the General Fund should the Board agree with Staff's recommendation.

LT. BUTLER advised he is recommending the replacement of Car 94 which has over 102,000 miles and Car 93 which is a 2003 model with 95,500 miles.  The cost of repairs goes up with the age of these cars.  There are two additional cars which have over 100,000 miles at this time.  The new cruisers would be purchased under the State contract and will meet all specifications required by the Sheriff's Office.  The Township should be able to get four to five years of use from them.

MR. BORCHERS stated he agreed with Lt. Butler's comments and it makes sense to purchase two police cruisers at this time.

MR. BECK noted that Staff is recommending the purchase of two cruisers and the Fiscal Officer is advising that funds are available from the General Fund for the second car.

The roll call vote for the above expenditures was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to establish a Temporary Appropriation 1-G-2 in the amount of $26,100.00.  Mr. Bryant seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

Mr. Beck moved to approve an expenditure in an amount not to exceed $26,028.00 for the purchase of a police cruiser.  Mrs. Leis seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'aye'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

MR. BECK moved to authorize Carol Sims and Ken Bryant to attend planning/zoning training sessions on January 27 and February 24 at Blue Ash Recreation Center.  Mrs. Leis seconded the motion and the roll call vote was as follows: Mr. Beck - 'aye'; Mr. Bryant - 'abstain'; Mrs. Leis - 'aye'.

The meeting adjourned at 9:34 p.m.
  

Back to Top